Opinion

First Things First is the best debate show in sports, and it isn't close

By Jonah Eduard ·

Sports debate television has a reputation, and it earned it. Manufactured outrage, takes built to go viral rather than to be right, and hosts arguing past each other until the commercial break. So it’s worth saying plainly: First Things First on FS1 is the best show in the genre, and in 2026 it finally got the recognition to prove it.

The chemistry is real

The show runs on three voices that actually fit together.

Most debate shows feel like strangers booked to disagree. First Things First feels like friends who disagree about everything and enjoy it, and that’s much more fun to watch.

It respects the audience

The show’s best trick is that the arguments are real. When Wright makes a case for a quarterback or against a team, he brings numbers and history. The best debate is one where you come away knowing something you didn’t, and this show delivers that more often than any of its competitors. The jokes land because the hosts know the sports cold.

The industry has noticed

This year the show earned its first Sports Emmy nomination for best studio show, up against four ESPN programs. That’s a big deal for a debate show, a format the awards have mostly ignored. FOX has also locked in Wright with a long-term extension, and Awful Announcing has called the program FS1’s flagship daily show, with both viewers and critics.

FOX also showed its confidence over the summer. During the 2026 World Cup it moved the show to 10 a.m. Eastern, head-to-head with ESPN’s First Take. You don’t schedule a show against the biggest program in the genre unless you think it can hold its own.

It’s been building to this for years

The show premiered on September 5, 2017, with Cris Carter and Nick Wright. It went through the lineup changes that most morning shows go through, with Wildes joining in 2020 and Broussard after that. That’s when it found its identity. Nine years in, it has the rarest thing in sports TV: a cast people tune in for regardless of the day’s topic.

The bottom line

If you’ve written off sports debate TV, First Things First is the show that might change your mind. It’s smart without being stuffy, loud without being empty, and funnier than anything else in the genre. Watch it on weekdays on FS1, and use our schedule to find FS1’s live games once the debating is done.

Sources

← All posts