Opinion
A 24-team College Football Playoff is a bad idea
College football’s best feature has always been its regular season. One bad Saturday in October could end a championship run, so every week felt like a playoff game. The 12-team playoff already loosened that. A 24-team playoff would throw most of it away.
What’s on the table
The College Football Playoff and ESPN are in the final stages of a deal to expand the field to 24 teams, likely starting in 2027. The format under discussion:
- Automatic bids for the four Power 4 conference champions and the highest-ranked Group of 6 team.
- 19 at-large bids.
- First-round byes for seeds 1 through 8, which would also host games.
- The first two rounds played on campus.
ESPN has reportedly offered about $345 million a year more for the bigger bracket. Reports also say the deal could change or eliminate the Power 4 conference championship games and push the season start a week earlier.
Nineteen at-large bids is the problem
Think about what 19 at-large spots means. Once you add the automatic qualifiers, you’re inviting teams that finished fourth or fifth in their own conference. A three- or four-loss team stops being a disappointment and becomes a playoff seed.
That changes how the whole season is played. When a loss in September barely matters, coaches have less reason to schedule tough non-conference games, and fans have less reason to care about a top-10 matchup before Thanksgiving. Even Nick Saban, who won more championships than anyone in the playoff era, put it simply: “There’s not 24 teams in the country that can win the national championship.”
Conference championships lose their meaning
Conference title games were the regular season’s grand finale: one game, everything at stake. In a 24-team bracket where both teams are already in, they turn into exhibitions with seeding implications. If the new deal shrinks or replaces those games, college football gives up one of its best Saturdays of the year in exchange for more first-round blowouts.
The players pay for it
A team without a bye that reaches the title game could play 17 or 18 games. That’s an NFL regular season for college athletes, many of whom will be weighing whether to sit out to protect their draft stock. Bowl games already lose stars to opt-outs; a longer bracket makes that worse, and the games fans paid for get weaker.
The 12-team format needed time
The 12-team playoff has had only two seasons. It’s produced great moments: playoff games on campus in December, and underdog runs nobody saw coming. It has also produced clear lessons about seeding and byes. The right move is to fix those details, not to double the field before anyone knows what the current one does to the sport long term.
The bottom line
Expansion to 24 is about money, not about crowning a better champion. The best team will still almost always come from the top eight. The difference is that everything before December will matter a little less. College football’s regular season is the best in sports because it’s unforgiving. Keep it that way.
While every game still matters, catch them all on the college football schedule.